Billie Jean

SouzaSouza Posts: 9,400
edited January 1970 in His Music & (Short) Films

She was more like a beauty queen
From a movie scene
I said, don't mind
But what do you mean
I am the one
Who will dance on the floor, in the round'
She says, 'I am the one who will dance
On the floor in the round'

She told me her name was Billie Jean
As she caused a scene
Then every head turned with eyes
That dreamed of being the one
Who will dance on the floor, in the round

People always told me,
Be careful of what you do
And don't go around
Breaking young girls' hearts
And mother always told me,
Be careful of who you love
And be careful what you do
Cause the lie becomes the truth

Billie Jean is not my lover
She's just a girl who claims that
I am the one
But the kid is not my son
She says I am the one
But the kid is not my son

For forty days and forty nights
I was on her side
But who can stand
When she's in demand
Her schemes and plans
Cause we danced on the floor, in the round
So take my strong advice
Just remember to always think twice
(Do think twice)
Do think twice
Hooo

She told my baby
We danced till three
And she looked at me
Then showed a photo
My baby cried
His eyes were like mine
Can we dance on the floor, in the round, babe

People always told me,
Be careful of what you do
And don't go around
Breaking young girls' hearts'
(Don't break no hearts)

But you came and stood right by me
Just a smell of sweet perfume
This happened much too soon
She called me to her room

Billie Jean is not my lover
She's just a girl who claims that
I am the one
But the kid is not my son
No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no

Billie Jean is not my lover
She's just a girl who claims that
I am the one
But the kid is not my son
No, no
She says I am the one
(Oh, babe)
But the kid is not my son

He, he, he
Hoo!
Hoo!

She says I am the one
But the kid is not my son
No, no, no
Billie Jean is not my lover
She's just a girl who claims that
I am the one
(You know what you did to me, babe)
But the kid is not my son
No, no, no, no
No, no

She says I am the one
But the kid is not my son

No, no

She says I am the one
You know what you did
She says he is my son
Breaking my heart, babe
She says I am the one

Billie Jean is not my lover
Billie Jean is not my lover
Billie Jean is not my lover
Billie Jean is not my lover
Billie Jean is not my lover


Freddie and I had discussions about it for hours, I won't bother you with it all and it took me some time so see, but in short it could be possible that he means this by it:

Who is the kid on the photo?
'His eyes were like mine', 'But the kid is not my son'. So the kid is Mike himself.

Who is Billie Jean?
Billie Jean is the public, the world. The public chose him to 'dance in the round', since he was a kid. The public is also in demand, they want new music, they want him to dance and sing and make music. The public also lies, we have seen enough examples through the years of lies about him. But his mother also says: "Don't go around breakin' young girls' hearts", because the public is also his fans. Which could mean that in some of his lyrics where he mentions a 'girl' he could also mean 'the public' or 'the fans'.

It's just a smart part of what we discussed, but with this and after S.T.U.D.Y.'s posts concerning TIAI, I think we can strip more of his songs, especially from thr BAD-era until Invincible, because he became more political from that time on.

I wonder what you guys come up with!

"For we wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this world, against spiritual wickedness in high places."

«134

Comments

  • teensyteensy Posts: 120
    <!-- s:shock: -->:shock:<!-- s:shock: --> Lady, I'm falling out of my chair!

    This could be a reason why I thought this song didn't make clear sense. When I listen to a song I try to imagine it in my head as a movie, but this song doesn't come together clearly. If you compare it to Beat It, that song has pretty clear message and video, but Billy Jean is abstract.
  • MJJ1982MJJ1982 Posts: 1,282
    Does anyone remember the (possible) explanation from Another part of me?
  • SarahliSarahli Posts: 4,265
    Indeed Michael is talking to us through his songs and sometimes we have to read between the lines.
    In this same song I just wanted to point out the sentence "cause the lie becomes the truth" as Michael omitted to pronounce it in TII rehearsal while perfoming Billy Jean. It was surely to highlight it. The lie has really became the truth nowadays and as I like to say to tell the truth has become a revolutionary act. People have even been killed to have told the truth. That's why this sentence is very important.
    Nevertheless the Truth always prevails thanks to God.

    God Bless you.

    I love MJ
  • misha86misha86 Posts: 508
    "cause the lie becomes the truth"

    this line has bothered me about this song for so long...i use to argue that the son was his kid because at one point he admits that he "danced" with her in the round and then at the end he says the lie becomes the truth and also he gets in the bed with her in the video

    but like most mj songs what you think he is talking about he is not... <!-- s:lol: -->:lol:<!-- s:lol: --> so good topic souza
  • misha86misha86 Posts: 508
    :shock: Lady, I'm falling out of my chair!

    This could be a reason why I thought this song didn't make clear sense. When I listen to a song I try to imagine it in my head as a movie, but this song doesn't come together clearly. If you compare it to Beat It, that song has pretty clear message and video, but Billy Jean is abstract.
    actually beat it doesnt make sense either because at one point he is like "just beat and it and run" then towards the end he is like saying just do it and not be scared...

    [2nd Verse]
    You Better Run, You Better Do What You Can
    Don't Wanna See No Blood, Don't Be A Macho Man
    You Wanna Be Tough, Better Do What You Can
    So Beat It, But You Wanna Be Bad


    here he is saying run

    [4th Verse]
    You Have To Show Them That You're Really Not Scared
    You're Playin' With Your Life, This Ain't No Truth Or Dare
    They'll Kick You, Then They Beat You,
    Then They'll Tell You It's Fair
    So Beat It, But You Wanna Be Bad


    here is saying show them you not scared...but earlier he said not be macho and no he is saying be macho..this dont make sense...lol
  • teensyteensy Posts: 120
    :shock: Lady, I'm falling out of my chair!

    This could be a reason why I thought this song didn't make clear sense. When I listen to a song I try to imagine it in my head as a movie, but this song doesn't come together clearly. If you compare it to Beat It, that song has pretty clear message and video, but Billy Jean is abstract.
    actually beat it doesnt make sense either because at one point he is like "just beat and it and run" then towards the end he is like saying just do it and not be scared...

    [2nd Verse]
    You Better Run, You Better Do What You Can
    Don't Wanna See No Blood, Don't Be A Macho Man
    You Wanna Be Tough, Better Do What You Can
    So Beat It, But You Wanna Be Bad


    here he is saying run

    [4th Verse]
    You Have To Show Them That You're Really Not Scared
    You're Playin' With Your Life, This Ain't No Truth Or Dare
    They'll Kick You, Then They Beat You,
    Then They'll Tell You It's Fair
    So Beat It, But You Wanna Be Bad


    here is saying show them you not scared...but earlier he said not be macho and no he is saying be macho..this dont make sense...lol

    <!-- s:shock: -->:shock:<!-- s:shock: --> <!-- s:o -->:o<!-- s:o --> *falls out chair* <!-- s:lol: -->:lol:<!-- s:lol: --> <!-- s:lol: -->:lol:<!-- s:lol: -->

    Your right! Your right! I did notice that. I think the story is more clear and easier to take as is. The gang thing is easier to see, and the song is easy to conform to that idea. But who ever he is struggling against is probaly like a ganster organization.

    It seems that the story is that he needs to run away from these people because they are dangerous. He even knows that blood will be spilled if he associates with them. The smart the to do is to run away.

    The world he is entering or lives in is treacherous. Life or death. Showing fear is not an option. They will kick as a warning. Then beat you. When their done with you, they'll tell you it was fair. As if they have the right, like the own you (slave).

    By saying that he is playing with his life, it's seem like their is a way out or that submission is the best course. Like whatever he's going to do, either fightback or building his own dominance, will cause a marked difference in the life he lead before.
    Yet, even in his making power-plays, gaining dominance/independance, they still have the power to met out punishment (kick you, then they beat you). They can even assault and batter someone, as if police authorities won't be able to help you(tell you it's fair.

    So the song is about a struggle between continued submission/getting out (beat it) or taking an offensive stance against them (show them how funky, strong is your fight).

    <!-- s:?: -->:?:<!-- s:?: -->
  • teensyteensy Posts: 120
    "cause the lie becomes the truth"

    this line has bothered me about this song for so long...i use to argue that the son was his kid because at one point he admits that he "danced" with her in the round and then at the end he says the lie becomes the truth and also he gets in the bed with her in the video

    but like most mj songs what you think he is talking about he is not... <!-- s:lol: -->:lol:<!-- s:lol: --> so good topic souza

    You another that bothered me is in this song, Dirty Diana, and Dangerous, it's obvious he's is fooling around with the villianess of the song. It also, show that he has a girlfriend or wife already.
    She told my baby
    We danced till three
    And she looked at me
    Then showed a photo
    My baby cried
    His eyes were like mine
    Can we dance on the floor, in the round, babe

    Even thought the villaness cause him trouble and heartache, he goes back to her.
    But I loved it, cause it's Dangerous

    So, he laments these woman, yet was fooling around, cheating, and loves it. What's up with that? <!-- s:? -->:?<!-- s:? --> I just thought he was a groupie-sex slut. Maybe his songs have more meaning than that. <!-- s;) -->;)<!-- s;) -->
  • misha86misha86 Posts: 508
    what im thinking is that he it not talking about women in the songs at all...if we replace girls with something else it would probly make alot more sense
  • teensyteensy Posts: 120
    what im thinking is that he it not talking about women in the songs at all...if we replace girls with something else it would probly make alot more sense

    Maybe the woman is the fans and some of the public. The villian shows hurtful pictures and say lying things that make his baby cry.
  • suomursusuomursu Posts: 111
    Okay this could be quite far-fetched but you know Come together lyrics

    Come together, right now
    Over me


    And you know the saying over my dead body

    So could that be some kind of clue? I mean he clearly wants us to come together as an army of L.O.V.E, but since he is not dead, we can't come together over his dead body, so we'll just come together over him.

    Just a thought...
  • Leah-KimLeah-Kim Posts: 507
    Okay this could be quite far-fetched but you know Come together lyrics

    Come together, right now
    Over me


    And you know the saying over my dead body

    So could that be some kind of clue? I mean he clearly wants us to come together as an army of L.O.V.E, but since he is not dead, we can't come together over his dead body, so we'll just come together over him.

    Just a thought...

    Except MJ only covered that song not wrote it!! The Beatles did it before MJ. I think anything going this far back means nothing imo....
  • misha86misha86 Posts: 508
    First of all thank you Freddie01 for showing me how to strip lyrics, which made me think of giving this it's own category. This new forum category is to make you reread all the lyrics again to see what he could have meant by them. As he says himself in This Is It, "That's why I write these kind of songs, you know. To give some sense of awareness and awakening and hope to people."

    Freddie showed me how to strip Billie Jean, and I think he has a great theory with this. Let me first show you the lyrics:

    She was more like a beauty queen
    From a movie scene
    I said, don't mind
    But what do you mean
    I am the one
    Who will dance on the floor, in the round'
    She says, 'I am the one who will dance
    On the floor in the round'

    She told me her name was Billie Jean
    As she caused a scene
    Then every head turned with eyes
    That dreamed of being the one
    Who will dance on the floor, in the round

    People always told me,
    Be careful of what you do
    And don't go around
    Breaking young girls' hearts
    And mother always told me,
    Be careful of who you love
    And be careful what you do
    Cause the lie becomes the truth

    Billie Jean is not my lover
    She's just a girl who claims that
    I am the one
    But the kid is not my son
    She says I am the one
    But the kid is not my son

    For forty days and forty nights
    I was on her side
    But who can stand
    When she's in demand
    Her schemes and plans
    Cause we danced on the floor, in the round
    So take my strong advice
    Just remember to always think twice
    (Do think twice)
    Do think twice
    Hooo

    She told my baby
    We danced till three
    And she looked at me
    Then showed a photo
    My baby cried
    His eyes were like mine
    Can we dance on the floor, in the round, babe

    People always told me,
    Be careful of what you do
    And don't go around
    Breaking young girls' hearts'
    (Don't break no hearts)

    But you came and stood right by me
    Just a smell of sweet perfume
    This happened much too soon
    She called me to her room

    Billie Jean is not my lover
    She's just a girl who claims that
    I am the one
    But the kid is not my son
    No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no

    Billie Jean is not my lover
    She's just a girl who claims that
    I am the one
    But the kid is not my son
    No, no
    She says I am the one
    (Oh, babe)
    But the kid is not my son

    He, he, he
    Hoo!
    Hoo!

    She says I am the one
    But the kid is not my son
    No, no, no
    Billie Jean is not my lover
    She's just a girl who claims that
    I am the one
    (You know what you did to me, babe)
    But the kid is not my son
    No, no, no, no
    No, no

    She says I am the one
    But the kid is not my son

    No, no

    She says I am the one
    You know what you did
    She says he is my son
    Breaking my heart, babe
    She says I am the one

    Billie Jean is not my lover
    Billie Jean is not my lover
    Billie Jean is not my lover
    Billie Jean is not my lover
    Billie Jean is not my lover


    Freddie and I had discussions about it for hours, I won't bother you with it all and it took me some time so see, but in short it could be possible that he means this by it:

    Who is the kid on the photo?
    'His eyes were like mine', 'But the kid is not my son'. So the kid is Mike himself.

    Who is Billie Jean?
    Billie Jean is the public, the world. The public chose him to 'dance in the round', since he was a kid. The public is also in demand, they want new music, they want him to dance and sing and make music. The public also lies, we have seen enough examples through the years of lies about him. But his mother also says: "Don't go around breakin' young girls' hearts", because the public is also his fans. Which could mean that in some of his lyrics where he mentions a 'girl' he could also mean 'the public' or 'the fans'.

    It's just a smart part of what we discussed, but with this and after S.T.U.D.Y.'s posts concerning TIAI, I think we can strip more of his songs, especially from thr BAD-era until Invincible, because he became more political from that time on.

    I wonder what you guys come up with!


    I came here to post a discussion but there is no thread thingy for off the wall or thriller? is that on purpose?
  • suomursusuomursu Posts: 111
    Oh, I know Beatles made the song first but Michael chose to sing it for SOME reason. But as I said, my theory was far-fetched.

    But I do think that this whole thing was in the back of his mind quite early. I mean the cover of Dangerous album is very interesting and little hints could be found in many places. But I do admid that some of us might exaggarate things a BIT <!-- s;) -->;)<!-- s;) -->
  • Michael had sense in all his songs. He wrote some sense and awareness to people, to give people hope.

    Smooth Criminal - Moonwalker version.
    (search on youtube) Strange text.
  • InfinityladyInfinitylady Posts: 1,006
    Hmmmm, interesting how you broke that down.
  • Thanks for the posting <!-- s:) -->:)<!-- s:) --> <!-- s:) -->:)<!-- s:) -->

    *Mind is clear of confusion*
  • I get what you are saying with billie jean...makes sense. With this in mind, the lyric."just remember to always think twice" I see him warning future entertainers to think twice before they decide to take on the music industry and the public. "I could smell her sweet perfume...it happened rather soon" It's true, the industry and fans call to you and it is intoxicating. You cant just leave stardom behind. "be careful what you do before the lie become the truth" That is a prophecy for MJ! Isn't that true! The lie of him being a ped...(I can't even type the sick word) became the truth over night!
  • misha86misha86 Posts: 508
    I get what you are saying with billie jean...makes sense. With this in mind, the lyric."just remember to always think twice" I see him warning future entertainers to think twice before they decide to take on the music industry and the public. "I could smell her sweet perfume...it happened rather soon" It's true, the industry and fans call to you and it is intoxicating. You cant just leave stardom behind. "be careful what you do before the lie become the truth" That is a prophecy for MJ! Isn't that true! The lie of him being a ped...(I can't even type the sick word) became the truth over night!

    i think billy jean is the devil, notice in the video is "sleeps" with her at the end but its just an entitiy..
  • I think the gangs in 'beat it' could be the powers that be the ones that you don't see and the ones that you do. The socialistic drug dealers and the media or greedy wolves in sheep clothing and stalkers.
  • I lived through a Beat It situation. A gang member stole my sisters bike/ 10 speed, and when I came home from college on my summer break of '97 I couldn't believe it, so, while I was outside at about 8pm no particular night I thought I saw a guy about my age 18, on a 10 speed that looked like my sisters bike, which was stolen about a month before. So I said to myself if this boy comes back in front of my house with my sisters stolen bike I am going to stop him., and he came riding back around in the street and when I saw him a little ways back I started walking towards the street to stop infront of him. My body was field with adrenaline and I was not about to let him keep riding on my sisters stolen bike. I don't think so! So I said excuse me, but where did you get this bike from and he told me that he got it from another guy so I told him that it was my sisters bike and it was stolen and then I said you have to get off. He flipped his top shirt open and said 'I don't want any trouble' yes he showed me his gun in his pants and I said there is no trouble, you are on a pink 10speed bike that doesn't belong to you. I said 'I don't want to make trouble either, but you need to get off this bike and if your friend comes back with you to claim this bike then we can talk. As this is going on the police pulled up right behind me. So as soon as the guy on my sisters bike realized that the police was behind me he got off of the bike and tried to walk away but the officers stopped him and sure enough he was a drug dealer and had an unregistered weapon on him. One less bad guy off the streets of Chicago. When I look at the 'beat it' video I think of alot of brave or macho people in the world that do the right thing but sometimes don't get a chance to live to tell it. God be with you all. Because he had someone with me that day and I hope he has someone with you.
  • lomaloma Posts: 1,366
    Like the beginning of HIStory says, he doesn't sing it if he doesn't mean it. <!-- s;) -->;)<!-- s;) -->
  • I guest alot of people are like tongue twister. His music keeps me dancing.
  • what im thinking is that he it not talking about women in the songs at all...if we replace girls with something else it would probly make alot more sense
    I think that in the later songs, like Heaven Can Wait, or You Are My Life he sings about his children... and in Speechless it's about love he feels for God. But I could be wrong. <!-- s:oops: -->:oops:<!-- s:oops: -->
  • Sorry, but you are wrong.
  • Sorry, but you are wrong.
    OK <!-- s:lol: -->:lol:<!-- s:lol: -->
    Do you have an explanation?
Sign In or Register to comment.